Breaking bad, as it has been all season, was greeted with effusive praise for its emotionally satisfying conclusion, even though the climax. However, after years of industry people getting flooded with spec 30 rock and sopranos scripts, the process has changed a little. Dexters terrible final season and how breaking bad. And vince gilligan, the creator and show runner of breaking bad. Nor is it about the similarities between two men who break the law. Hes not a bad actor, but the part was clearly not written for him. The wire, like the sopranos and breaking bad, does find. It really is one of the best american tv shows out there at the moment. Walter white, felina, breaking bad walter whites explanation for what was arguably, the most epic midlife crisis ever, pretty much sums up the way i felt while watching nearly every episode of breaking bad. Fabulous casts in both series and great writing in both. It tells the story of walter white bryan cranston, a struggling high school chemistry teacher diagnosed with inoperable lung cancer, who, together with his former student jesse pinkman. Everything that made the sopranos work has been picked apart and ripped off to create the next wave of tv drama.
How tony soprano paved the way for donald trump vanity fair. Screenwriting article why breaking bad is so breaking good. In 2015, the clinically depressed pilot of germanwings flight 9525 deliberately crashed his plane into the side of a mountain in france, killing 150 people although the breaking bad incident was an accident caused by a depressed air traffic controller, whereas the latter was intentionally done by a pilot. The sopranos set the stage for that golden era of television. Find out surprising and entertaining facts about german tv, best programs, what germans like to watch and differences to other countries. But the most likely answer is either the sopranos or the wire. The dream sequences of the sopranos are an obvious illustration of this ability to move laterally in a storyline and not straight ahead, but there are others. Tony soprano james gandolfini is a new jerseybased. You see, in this space a few years ago, i declared breaking bad the best tv show of all time. Klosterman concluded that, in the world of breaking bad, goodness and badness are simply complicated choices, no different than anything else.
Though there are no zombies to be had in breaking bad, theres certainly a similar amount of bloodshed and bodies in the course of this fun horror romp. I always say, its a pity that the sopranos was made, otherwise true detective was without doubt the absolute best tv serie. Compare that to the more than 10 million people who tuned in for breaking bad. Ask people who have seen both shows which one is better, and you will. Many a times, ive come across breaking bad fanboys bragging about how good the show was. The importance of the writers the difficult men of the title being the focus of the book on shows such as the wire, the sopranos, deadwood and mad men. And while breaking bad fans grew frustrated with skyler white anna gunn, sopranos carmela soprano edie falco frequently held her own. I almost always dismissed it and never gave a lot of attention to it. Better call saul offers a fitting eulogy on the television. The sopranos is a deconstructive criminal procedural series centered around north jersey mob boss tony soprano, who after a panic attack secretly begins seeing a therapist. Based on a nonfiction book cowritten by simon and the wire. The main pleasure of this book is its detailed descriptions of the creation. The rhetoric of individualism in the sopranos, breaking bad, and. Breaking bad proved that kind of quality could be produced on basic cable and helped expand the playing field, while raising the bar of expectation.
So this post is a small exploration of some of these similarities in how these complex and intriguing characters are written. Available on kindle ebook and can be read on any device with the free. Its certainly true that individuals make a difference, i do not discount that. The sopranos is better than breaking bad campus news. Being based on a prominent comic book series, theres no shortage of. I rate the sopranos, breaking bad and the wire as the three must watch television. I had not heard much about breaking bad, i took a chance. I watch a lot of tv shows i find them more entertaining than movies, and breaking bad is a gem, probably up there in the top ten of the last 10 years. Breaking bad s walter white may have settled in comfortably to his role as meth kingpin, but his journey to that point over the first two seasons was a transformation of epic proportions. The greatest tv drama of the past 25 years, the finals. It tells the story of walter white bryan cranston, a struggling high school chemistry teacher diagnosed with lung cancer. Yes, saul is getting a prequel, but i dont expect any followup or alternate ending or spinoffs from the ending to breaking bad.
Similarities between chris moltisanti and jesse pinkman. Kostko points out in his book why we love sociopaths, tonys story represents an aspect. So for those of you on my newsletter, you know i posed the question last week of, which article did you want me to writewhy breaking bad is so good, or why the fast and the furious franchise is so successful. The focus on a flawed and corrupted leading man has been used to form breaking bad, mad men, the shield, and countless others. Hilarious reality ensues as his therapy coincides with him sending his troublesome, sociopathic mother livia into a nursing home when it becomes apparent that shes no longer able to take care of herself. My instinctual and reasoned guess is its shakespearean dimensions. In it, david chase, rather flippantly, refers to holstens as a death scene, although it was originally conceived slightly different as more of. As im writing on the internet, i likely dont have to explain to you just why breaking bad is having such a successful final run of episodes. How did you get this number, and the recently released ebook up the down volcano. The first because of the feigned madness that hamlet assumes, and the actual madness that his. The story isnt linear in the sopranos for the simple reason that peoples minds dont work in straightahead fashion, and at heart the show is about a single mindtonys. Week after week, audiences watching these series felt like they were watching the great american novel unfold, and both of. Of course, i was aware of the sopranos and how it trailblazed a market for all of these.
Breaking bad is a lot of fun and honestly maybe more tightly plotted, but to me its just a really well done thriller whereas sopranos is a deep exploration of psychology and vomits uncontrollably the human condition. Shows such as the wire, breaking bad, the sopranos, mad men, deadwood, the shield tackled issues of. Christopher moltisanti vs jesse pinkman the sopranos vs breaking bad. No spoilers here for the final season of breaking bad, which launched sunday on a typically tragic note, but its time to compare notes. Being based on a prominent comic book series, theres no shortage of worldbuilding and thrilling action in this zombie thriller. Ask people who have seen both shows which one is better, and you will get a thats obvious, followed by two words. What i have noticed is how many similarities there are between the sopranos and another recent tv phenomenon, breaking bad. An egyptian tv show is being accused of brazenly copying breaking bad. Not similar at all, but, both are tremendous shows in their own right. The sopranos and breaking bad are two of the best hammocks of the past decade. Chase showed how much storytelling ambition you could bring to television, and it didnt take long for everybody else to rise to his challenge. As he put it in one of our interviews for my book difficult men. Or maybe breaking bad or possibly, at a stretch, mad men.
For all of the work put into breaking bad, this series was a major accomplishment. Breaking bad is an american crime drama television series created and produced by vince gilligan. The enduring, understated brilliance of better call saul. The sopranos has always been a long time favourite show of mine. Breaking bad is an american neowestern crime drama television series created and produced by vince gilligan. Breaking bad refusing to fall into a whack of the week mob drama trap, the sopranos took bold creative risks with its narrative remember tony trapped in. And to read some guy saying that buffy is what real tv is about and the sopranos should be axed this is a disgrace. Two things strike me, firstly, vince gilligan, like david chase, is not shy of comparing his tv show with others.
The show originally aired on the amc network for five seasons, from january 20, 2008, to september 29, 20. Ive watched breaking bad, dexter, the sopranos, lost and. Cables bad boys are back hitting delicious new lows on. Many readers emailed me regarding a recent interview of david chase by television bloggers matt zoller sietz and allan sepinwall for their book the sopranos sessions. When you have an entire cast that share appropriate periodregional accents, it becomes jarring and downright bizarre to hear. Walter white is arguably as much an archetypal difficult man as tony soprano. The problem is those words will be different 50 percent of the time. The second season was sad, i do not even understand that the season has the same name. Breaking bads showrunner vince gilligan is, in stark contrast, is a. Breaking bad is a bit more comicbooky, but wins out on pure story. Anna faktorovich why is breaking bad one of the best television series i have seen over the last few years. And while breaking bad fans grew frustrated with skyler white anna gunn, sopranos carmela soprano edie falco frequently held her own against her husband and was every bit as complex as he was. Similarities between livia and mary carmelas mother. The sopranos constantly name checks other tv shows, i think to compare the quality of their own with others.
Breaking bad is an excellent tv series but it never raised half the themes lost did, lost was always going to be polarizing simply because of the nature of the show, it was scififantasy afterall. Look upon my works, ye mighty, and despair, said vince gilligan and company. On average, germans watch tv for about 242 minutes about 4 hours daily. While the series was both superbly acted and shot, for me, it was the writing that made this show a onceinalifetime experience.
The story arc has similarities with hamlet and macbeth. Ozark star jason bateman responds to breaking bad comparisons the two crime dramas have a lot in common but can netflixs new series really measure up. Its not hard to see how tony paved the way for the likes of breaking bads walter white, mad mens don draper, or dexters namesake lead character, to name just a few. Aside from this comparison being moot, i do feel like breaking bad is much more of a crime show than sopranos is. Sopranos at times is much more of a drama that has very little to do with crime, exploring existential ideas through the dark side of the american dream. You might still get somewhere writing a spec of an existing show. The breakthroughs of the next few years the wire, mad men, breaking bad couldnt have happened without the sopranos kicking the door down. Love, death, desire and betrayal in americas favorite gangster family, glen gabbard draws on his experiences as a. While breaking bad and better call saul have a lot of surface similarities settings, characters, gorgeous desert vistas that would make you think. Without question, the sopranos and breaking bad are two of the. For a fan of hbo shows and the new golden age of tv this book is essential reading. The difference is that while sepinwalls book is more about the shows. Along with hits like the sopranos, this show helped propel hbo into the. It is simply another serie and has nothing to do with the first.
Without question, the sopranos and breaking bad are two of the best hammocks of the past decade. Cables bad boys are back hitting delicious new lows on the sopranos and the shield by melanie mcfarland, seattle postintelligencer television critic updated 10. The parallels go beyond the plot and extend to the protagonist. We miss the stellar breaking bad but luckily, these bingeworthy shows have some similar. Spoilers the sopranos vs the wire vs breaking bad which. Whats interesting is just how similar the final 12 episodes of dexter so far are to the final eight episodes of breaking bad so far. The show originally aired on the amc network for five seasons, from january 20, 2008 to september 29, 20. Agent jack bauer works for ctu counter terrorist unit dealing with terrorists assassination attempts, nuclear a. More striking than the similarities between better call saul and breaking bad are the differences between the two. First off, the choice of john doman as rodrigo borgia was a bad one. The sopranos, breaking bad, mad men reveal many similarities. Breaking bad, the sopranos or the wire page 4 steve. The show gets in the heart and soul of the mafia and family life just like the godfather trilogy, it gets to the heart and soul of each individual character.
Nowadays, though, its more advisable to write a tv pilot based on your own original idea. Or, rather, whats interesting is that both stories started in fairly. It was a sunday evening in 2014, i was bored to death. A lot of stuff have been inspired from the sopranos in the making of breaking bad. Visit the writers rooms at the sopranos, the wire, breaking bad, and mad men.
193 1577 550 724 551 1566 1438 577 575 640 514 680 329 1223 1373 49 1629 592 1599 1305 320 49 1629 961 713 631 521 1110 1402 766 480 488 968 525 1032 1092 1424 375 140 962 1429 123